Monday, January 10, 2022

Grappling with Graptolites: Paleozoic "Sawtooth" Index Fossils —Are you Jelly?

      Graptolites (or more precisely Graptolithina) are extinct colonial marine animals that are an excellent index fossil for parts of the Paleozoic period; individual species denote well-defined time frames within, especially, the Ordovician, Silurian and Devonian periods. The fossil remains present mostly as shiny, graphite-looking sawtoothed pieces. A big paleontology mystery up until the 1980’s was what these pieces represented. Early descriptors, including Linnaeus, were mystified by the “writing on the rock,” considering even hieroglyphics as a possible origin. He included them in “inorganic mineralizations and incrustations which resembled actual fossils.” In 1768’s, Systematic Naturae he included one species as a possible plant fossil. He also included a figure of a "fossil or graptolite of a strange kind.”




           These serrated, delicate, detailed fossils, represent about 200 million years from the Cambrian through the Pennsylvanian portion of the Carboniferous. 




           These useful Index fossils denote rocks to within a million year period within the Paleozoic.  The Ordovician was a particularly prolific time for graptolites, with rapid changes in morphology. In addition, early graptolites were sessile but rapidly evolved to be floating animals. Their fossil remains are found in shale and clay stone. Another prolific Ordovician index fossil, conodonts or conodont elements, are found mostly in limestone and other CaCO3-rich environments.{ More on conodonts during our next post.}






      Paleontologists use them to correlate the age of rocks, particularly mudstones or shales, based on changes in the serrated blades. Oil and gas geologists found graptolites particularly helpful in correlating borehole samples throughout a geologic basin. But, we didn’t have fossilized portions of the entire animal, just the shiny sawtooth bits.



            The rather shocking discovery of soft parts of the animal revealed graptolites resemble present-day jellyfish. These floating colonial animals had a proto-neural tube. But, only the floating strands of detailed serrated portions in the fossil record led to many incorrect hypotheses of their origin. Now, we believe graptolites looked like a an odd-shaped jellyfish as seen in these artists’ renderings:



              This rendering is even more bizarre:




      
      From long, shiny bit of graphite-looking straight shapes





  to the more elaborate swirling shapes, graptolites gave geologists a solid index fossil for use in oil and gas correlation between oil wells, long before we knew what the whole animals looked like.




The type 
locality for the Ordovician is located here in the U.K. As Ordovician. Note also, Silures, type locality for the Silurian, is located just to the south. {The Silurian was a time of great silence on the earth; almost no volcanic activity has been recorded during this Ordovician-adjacent time.}




Have you seen either graptolites or conodonts in rocks in the field? Odd that these two most unusual creatures would be the basis for so much geologic correlation, without knowing what the whole animals looked like. The Ordovician was a quite wild ride.

Happy New Year to all visitors to Partial Ellipsis of the Sun;we are glad you are here!

To 2022, with Great Expectations for Groundhog Day, 2/2/22! 
Steph

Bonus: Looking ahead: Here’s an image of  conodont elements in an SEM image as well as an artist rendering of the elements in the inside the mouth of that Ordovician beast, the stuff of nightmares. Conodonts, microfossils varied and extraordinaire, will be featured in our next post.











 


32 comments:

  1. Preview: conodonts are silceous and occur primarily in limestone and other CaCO3 rich rocks so paleontologists just fizz away the matrix, leaving a fossil assemblage. It was one of the more exciting parts of micropaleontology at U of AZ. So. Much. Limestone. Chucky-Jam. Full. Of. Fossils!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Sorry about the &#@% formatting at the end of this post. But, at least this graptolite post is out there now.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Memories are stored in the spaces between . . ..

    Perfect for National Write your Name in Morse Code Day!

    . . .
    -
    .
    . - - .
    . . . .

    ReplyDelete
  4. Discussing these delicate, serrated fossils is all well and good, but what about that guy in your third picture above, the one tossing that pterosaur off the cliff? He's clearly thinking about practical applications.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, jan. I enjoyed that immensely!

      Also, it's your month -- happy Jan 2022 while we're at it.

      Delete
    2. Nothing happy about not being able to find my blog posts with a search function -- everyone's post matches "jan"!

      I may have mentioned that my local library in NJ used to robocall when a reserved book became available. The message would start with the borrower's name, which in my case it pronounced "January", assuming that's what it's short for.

      Delete
    3. You and January Jones ;-)!

      February is coming. . .

      Looking forward greatly to Groundhog Day this year, 2-2-22, when covid models in Colorado, at least, point to a sharp decline in cases.

      Delete
  5. Replies
    1. They are impressive.

      My brother is in Hawaii this week so we are getting first-hand reports from there. I remember seeing all those loud-speakers all over Kauai to warn people of tsunamis.

      Delete
  6. Also, I'll ADMIT to becoming a Wordle fan AFTER 3 days. The simplicity and the lack of ads is appealing. Plus, TODAY was a 3-time solution. Anyone else a Wordle fan? It's made me pay more attention to 5-letter WORDS. --STEPH--

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I've been wordling for about a week, though I'm not sure I'd say I'm a fan. Just compulsive. I like that it's over quickly, and that it then leaves you alone for the rest of the day. I also got the answer in 3 today, though I thought there was a good chance the answer would be the same word with the first letter replaced by the one that comes 3 places earlier in the alphabet. I picked the right one because I thought it was more politically correct. I always start with the same two words (STAIR / CLONE), to get the most common letters out of the way first, a strategy that apparently pisses off my sister-in-law.

      Delete
    2. The good news is that the game uses a list of 2,315 five-letter words, so in just six years, we'll be able to move on.

      Delete
    3. Ha! I was looking at a list of 150,000+ 5-letter words. I wonder if he'll update the database. (From the BIRTH to the DEATH of the Wordle CRAZE).

      Delete
    4. Am I the only one who has a sufficient number of ways to waste time?

      Delete
    5. 5 minutes or less of word joy a day? Sure, I THINK they are well SPENT. Plus, I am always paying attention to 5-letter WORDS now. Even Jeopardy had that as a category last week...

      Delete
    6. My mom is now hooked on Wordle. If I call her early in the morning she doesn't even say hello but begins with "D O _ _ E." She is having a blast with Wordle!

      I have had a super busy 2 weeks so I haven't played for awhile. With a nice week of break coming up, Bruno and I will have more time for Wordle, Sandhill cranes and hiking.

      Delete
  7. Replies
    1. I'm sure the most extensive libraries of underwater biological sounds are held by the navies of the major powers. (Gotta be able to tell a sub from a whale, krill, etc.) I'd be surprised if much of their content will be made available to GLUBS.

      I'm happy to note that the citations in the referenced paper include works by authors Fish, Salmon, and Bass (as well as Bird and Mann). I worked with the author of several cited papers in grad school.

      Delete
    2. That's awesome. Science AND a sense of humour? Yes!

      Delete
  8. I know that you (and many others) have promoted DuckDuckGo for their privacy policy. Apparently, so do right-wing conspiracy theorists. Now you know how I feel about the alt-right co-opting polo shirts and khakis, and the boogaloo boys claiming Hawaiian shirts!

    ReplyDelete
  9. I read all of Life as a Geological Force by Peter Westbroek in 2.5 hours last night. I highly recommend it. The thumbnail of Emiliania is inspired by this book.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. jan, let me know what you think of his narrative style.

      I'm thinking I will have the ninth graders read it for the Geology class I'm teaching this spring. They will like reading about slime and the coccoliths in chalk. Our geologic field trip to the I-70 road cut, Dinosaur Ridge, and Red Rocks will tie in well with exploring the geologic origins of where we are.

      Growing up in the CT River Valley, I did not realize that an extensional (rift) valley has a fairly unusual origin story... And the Jelly Bean Conglomerate will always be my favorite conglomerate.

      Delete
    2. Finished Westbroek's book. Not very impressed. Found his narrative style kind of rambling. Not at all a fan of Gaia. If Earth were homeostatic, you wouldn't, e.g., have positive-feedback loop of warming -> melting ice caps -> lower albedo -> more warming. Or, homeostatic earth would have done something to keep all those nasty plants from polluting its nice reducing atmosphere with all that awful oxygen.

      Delete
    3. It is, indeed, rambling. I think it's just what 9th graders might like as an intro to geology. . . precisely because he does ramble and perambulate and talk about walking around in the geology where you are.

      I think as a teaching tool (granddaughters?) it has merit because it is so un-textbook-like. My school is like that (no textbooks; the students create a book at the end of the block to summarize their learning).

      It has flaws, sure. I want them to be introduced to geology and perhaps come to love it as much as I do, so I'm coming to it from that perspective.

      We'll also do fun, challenging experiments and analysis, compare rocks and minerals, and take a day long field trip to Dinosaur Ridge, Red Rocks, and various roadcuts in the foothills.

      Capstone will be describing their individual rock samples, with a detailed origin story and analysis of any fossils, temperature and pressure gradients, extrusive vs intrusive where appropriate (all different and collected from my USGS and oil biz colleagues). We're reviving the Pet Rock but these samples are 2 kilograms and up...

      Delete
    4. Hmmm, you might want to steer clear of pet rocks with kiddos.

      Delete
    5. And with Zoë, too. Elmo's on fire!

      Delete
  10. New post on "From Circles to Squares and Back Again: Sandhill Crane March Migration, Crestone Conglomerate, and a Surprise Stupa!" is now up!

    Enjoy!

    ReplyDelete

So glad you visited Partial Ellipsis of the Sun! Please leave a comment and come back soon!